Wholly Cow Ice Cream’s Top 5 Ice Cream Flavors of 2025
If there’s one thing we take seriously around here, it’s ice cream. After another busy year of scooping, packaging pints, and taste-testing (tough job, we know), we’ve compiled a list of our Top 5 most popular ice cream flavors of 2025. These are the flavors customers come back for again and again, the ones that disappear fastest from the freezer, and the ones we’re most proud to put our name on.
1. Killa Vanilla
Our Signature Classic
Sometimes simple is unbeatable. Killa Vanilla is our signature flavor, made with three types of real vanilla extract and finished with vanilla bean flakes for a smooth, layered vanilla experience. It’s rich, aromatic, and anything but boring. If you think vanilla is “plain,” this one will change your mind fast.
2. Charleston Sea Turtle (Also Sold in Pints)
A Local Favorite with Serious Sweetness
This flavor has become a Charleston classic. Charleston Sea Turtle combines salted caramel ice cream, a caramel ribbon, and mini turtle milk chocolate caramel candies throughout. Sweet, salty, chocolatey, and indulgent, it’s one of our most requested pint flavors and a must-try if you love caramel-forward desserts.
3. Southern Pecan Praline (Also Sold in Pints)
Old-Fashioned, Done Right
Inspired by Southern dessert traditions, Southern Pecan Praline starts with old-fashioned caramel ice cream, then adds roasted praline-coated pecans and a salted caramel ribbon. It’s warm, nutty, and deeply comforting, like a classic Southern dessert frozen into scoopable perfection.
4. Mint Chocolate Chip
A Beloved Classic with a Fresh Spin
Cool, refreshing, and perfectly balanced, our Mint Chocolate Chip starts with smooth mint ice cream that’s fresh without being overpowering. It’s packed with rich chocolate chips in every bite, delivering that classic mint-and-chocolate combo done the Wholly Cow way — creamy, bold, and endlessly scoopable.
5. Very Chocolate
Not Your Average Chocolate
This one’s for the true chocolate lovers. Very Chocolate is a deeply rich chocolate ice cream loaded with layers of chocolate flavor that don’t hold back. It’s smooth, indulgent, and unapologetically chocolatey — proof that when it comes to chocolate, more really is more.
Honorable Mention: Chocolate Fetish
For the True Chocolate Lovers
We couldn’t leave this one out. Chocolate Fetish is a decadent, rich chocolate ice cream packed with chocolate chunks and finished with a dark chocolate fudge ribbon. If you believe there’s no such thing as “too much chocolate,” this flavor was made for you.
Want More Flavors?
These are just the fan favorites. You can explore all of our ice cream and sorbet flavors here
🍦 Our Flavors 🍦
Where to Find Wholly Cow Ice Cream
You can grab these flavors at select retailers near you:
Wholly Cow Store Locator
Or, for the full experience, swing by our shop on Johns Island in Charleston and try them fresh:
Wholly Cow Scoop Shop on Johns Island
Stop in, grab a scoop (or two), and taste why these flavors earned their spot as our Top 5 Flavors of 2025!
